Sam’s Club Jewelry Review | Are They Trustworthy?

Sam’s Club Jewelry Review | Are They Trustworthy?

Sam’s Club Jewelry Review | Are They Trustworthy?

Posted by Rebecca B. on 27th Sep 2019

Sam’s Club Jewelry Review

Sam’s Club Jewelry – A Review

Our Rating 3.6 out of 5.

Compare Sam’s Club Jewelry with James Allen.

Sam’s Club, much like other wholesaler chains, offer discounted prices on bulk home products and groceries. They are known for a wide selection of anything you might need at home and do offer diamonds as well.

However, their wide range of products does not extend to a wide range of diamonds, and you might be left wanting with a limited selection and a lack of knowledgeable assistance from staff.

Is Sam’s Club a  good choice for purchasing a diamond? This review will give you the in’s and out’s to make that decision.

James Allen

A Brief History

Sam’s Club is a members-only retailer who caters bulk deals directly to the consumer. It is the second-largest company in their market, featuring nearly 600 stores nationwide in the USA and with estimated sales of $57 million last year.

Direct competition to  Costco, Sam’s Club is still ever-growing, as people see the logic in bulk-buying groceries and household products to save money in the long run.

What Sam’s Club Offer

What Sam’s Club Offer

With a huge range of products on offer, customers can walk into the store and walk out with almost everything they might need, including diamonds.

Having diamonds sold at the same place where you can buy a bulk bag of crisps may seem like a great idea at first, but both the selection and stock are limited. Yes, there are some diamonds that you might pick up which are of decent quality, but the catch is that unless you know a substantial amount about diamonds yourself, there will be no one to help you understand diamonds and to help you make the right choice.

At Sam’s Club, you are able to choose between small selections of pre-set rings. Some are really stunning and of great quality, while others fall very short of the mark. You will have to have a great eye for diamond quality to ensure you purchase a diamond engagement ring worth its value.


What Makes Sam’s Club Stand Out?

Members-only – Having to be a member at Sam’s Club does offer customers the chance to find some great deals and discounts and to shop in bulk. This might help in scoring some good deals on engagement rings.

Reliable store – One thing about Sam’s Club that helps them stick out is that it is a trusted store by many families.

Engagement rings – Ready set rings might not be ideal for many, but some people are looking for a ring that is a no-fuss purchase. You might be lucky and find your ideal ring at Sam’s Club without having to custom design one of your own.

Many stores – Sam’s Club stores can be found in over 600 destinations across the USA. This saves customers having to travel far to view their inventory or to make a purchase.

Sam’s Club Pricing

Sam’s Club diamonds can often be low-quality diamonds, but they will have similar pricing to better quality diamonds from  James Allen and Blue Nile. Compared to these two online retailers, Sam’s Club does not stand up in value or price.

Some might find it convenient to be able to walk into a Sam’s Club and pick up a ring, pay and leave, instead of shopping online, choosing a setting, then a diamond and having it delivered. However, shopping online at James Allen or Blue Nile will definitely save you some money and value within your budget.

Custom Orders

Sam’s Club engagement rings come ready-made, with a set metal, setting and diamond or  gemstone. This limits customers to different choices when they are looking for a personalized ring.

To make the search for a unique ring even more difficult, there really isn’t a wide variety of choice at Sam’s Club. You are limited to the few options they have on the show, and will not be able to customize the ring unless you take it to another jeweler.

Website Ease of Use

The Sam’s Club website features all the products you would be able to find in store, including the engagement rings. Overall, the website is fairly easy to use and after a few selections, you will be on the page for engagement rings.

The filtering options are not ideal, and only let you filter rings based on their styles and settings, and not the actual properties of the diamond. Once again this leads to it being very difficult to ensure you are buying a good quality diamond, as most of the focus is set on the style of ring.

The images of the rings on the site are also stock photos, so you will not be seeing the actual ring until it has been purchased, or until you go into a store to view it up close.

Customer Service

Customer service at Sam’s Club is fairly good, with helpful staff on the floor to assist customers when needed. However, their training does not go as far as to help with crucial diamond information, which limits the customer greatly.

Full time Customer Support –The website offers queries and help whenever it might be needed. You will however not be able to receive knowledgeable help on all things diamonds, such as you would from sites like James Allen or Blue Nile.

Return Policy – The return policy on engagement rings will fall under the customer's return policy on other items bought from the store.

Shipping – If you order a ring online at Sam’s Club, they will have it shipped to you. This isn’t really a great choice though, if you are shopping online you should consider shopping at James Allen.

Sam’s Club Financing Options

Sam’s Club does offer a credit card for in store purchases, but it does not come with any interest-free options. It does help customers purchase an engagement ring on credit, but the interest does add quite a bit of an extra cost to the purchase.

Why You Should Choose Sam’s Club

  • Ready-made rings for an easy choice
  • 600 stores nationwide for easy access
  • Online shopping for engagement rings is made available for those not wanting to head to a store

Sam’s Club – For Household Goods and Not Diamonds

You might spend a couple of hours at Sam’s Club purchasing your household items in bulk, and might be wondering if you should make your engagement ring purchase there as well.

The short answer is no, you probably shouldn’t. Sam’s Club has a very small selection of ready set engagement rings to choose from, and they can be very varied in quality. With such a large purchase, you should stick to a bigger store like James Allen, who you know will offer you a very competitive price on high-quality diamonds and engagement rings.