Best Jewelers in Cincinnati for Diamonds

Sharif Khan
Sharif Khan
Last Updated    EST 
Affiliate links are highlighted in red. Learn more here.

Diamonds go hand in hand with special events in our lives. To some, these gems are an exclusive symbol of riches, but to most people, they come with additional sentimental value.

When you gift a diamond to your near and dear ones, you want it to deliver maximum impact on them. It does not matter whether you are gifting it as a symbol of purity and innocence or want the stone to symbolize how much you cherish the one you are giving it to. You hope that the present acts as a crowning jewel of your true feelings and desires.

Above all, you would want a gem that creates a lasting impression on your partner. But for it to achieve any of those goals, the diamond must also meet the tastes of the recipient. For instance, does your partner fancy red oval diamonds? Are they selective enough to turn down a diamond with blemishes? These are some of the questions you must settle before hitting the stores. If you do not, you might invest your entire fortune in something that will go unappreciated.

If you live in Cincinnati, you are wondering where to shop for the best diamond, given that the city does not have a diamond district. As such, jewelry shops are scattered all over the city, but you do not need to fret. Read this guide to uncover how to get the best deals on diamonds in Cincinnati.

Search & Watch Diamonds in 40X 360° HD Videos.

How to Buy Diamonds in Cincinnati

Invest in the Four Cs

You are likely planning to buy a diamond—chances are that you may do so shortly. But have you ever heard of the 4Cs? If not, you might just be itching for the worst shopping experience of your life.

James Allen Diamonds In HD

Diamonds are graded based on the Four Cs—cut, carat, color, and cut. In short, carat refers to the unit of measurement for the weight of the stone, which is why it is also commonly referred to as carat weight. One carat equals 0.2 grams. When buying diamonds, the higher the carat weight, the pricier the gem is. It is indeed a no-brainer.

Like the carat, the color aspect should not be hard to hack, either. The diamond color scale ranges from D, colorless, to Z, light yellow. However, we all have our choice of colors. The idea is to understand how the color affects the other aspects of the stone. For example, colorless diamonds reflect more light than colored ones. You must also understand the impact of color on the overall cost of the gem. In this regard, colored diamonds tend to be costlier than colorless ones. Red is the most expensive of colored diamonds, with yellow being the cheapest.

diamond cut refers to the design of the jewel for polishing. Do not confuse a diamond's cut with its shape. As you may expect, the shape only gives the raw dimensions of the stone. However, the cut brings out the symmetry and polish of the diamond. To paint a clearer picture, did you know that a diamond cut affects the jewel’s brilliance? Besides, it impacts the shape and softness of the stone. An excellent cut optimizes the diamond’s color and clarity.

Lastly, clarity refers to how eye-clean a diamond is. The clarity scale ranges from IF (internally flawless) to I3 (included grade 3). You can use this scale if you are in doubt. However, you will realize that it comes down to what appears eye-clean. Remember that some people love diamonds with inclusions, underscoring the importance of establishing tastes before gifting somebody a diamond.

By understanding these four essential elements, you are only halfway towards finding your preferred diamond in Cincinnati. The other half of the task involves locating an ideal store.

Diamond Cheat Sheet Blue Nile

Find a Reputable Store

Every diamond store you visit in Cincinnati will market its merchandise as the best. Of course, you do not expect them to put it any other way. However, you must read unrealistic claims since it is the only way you will sift through the hundreds of jewelers to home in on the best vendor.

First off, ensure that the store has an extensive industry presence. To do so, read a couple of online reviews. A vendor that has remained in operation for over a decade will likely be highly knowledgeable about diamonds. Such vendors must have witnessed thousands of return clients. When buying from their stores, they will probably recommend the best diamond for you.

Another hallmark of a reputable diamond jeweler in Cincinnati is the friendly customer experience. Some diamond stores exist for the sole motive of profit generation. For such vendors, nothing matters more than swaying you to buy their offers. It does not matter whether the jewelry suits you; they only care about cashing in. You will know them during your interactions at their stores. Instead of assisting you in locating your diamond, they will try to pressure you into buying one.

Besides, devious vendors are economical with information about the certification of their diamonds—another red flag. If a merchant deals in certified diamonds, why would they hold back any information? But if a vendor does so, it implies that their diamonds are not duly graded or that the grading lab is shady. You must shun these kinds of stores.

Lastly, could you check if the store offers a return policy? Diamonds do not come cheap; therefore, knowing that you can return the merchandise if it falls below your expectations is relieving.

Reputable Jewelers in Cincinnati


Richter & Phillips is famous for their comprehensive collection of diamond jewelry. The store offers an extensive range of engagement rings, wedding bands, and even designer collections. It is also your go-to store if you are looking for antique jewelry, diamond necklaces, and gem pendants.

The vendor offers free estimates, and their prices are industry competitive. Besides, their sales assistants are professionally trained to assist their clients in finding their desired diamonds. Additional services you will find here include jewelry cleaning, polishing, and refining. The store is located at 601 Main Street, Cincinnati, OH 45202.


Genesis is another reputable store where you can buy diamonds in Cincinnati. The store stocks a massive collection of diamonds, from bridal to eternity rings. If you are looking for the most exquisite branded diamonds, you will find them at this outlet.

Customer service is exceptional, evidenced by the numerous positive reviews the vendor has enjoyed throughout its 14-year existence. If their diamonds do not meet your style, you can take advantage of their 30-day return policy. The vendor is located at 8060 Montgomery Road, Suite 500.


SCHWARTZ JEWELERS comes only second to Richter and Phillips in terms of the oldest jewelry shops in Cincinnati. Since 1937, the store has continued to wow its clients with its classic and contemporary diamond jewelry. Furthermore, they have a stunning assortment of diamond pendants, necklaces, and bracelets. You can visit their physical stores at 6114 Hamilton Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45224.

Final thoughts

Buying diamonds in Cincinnati is mostly a hassle-free process. You only need to arm yourself with the requisite information before visiting any store. Since the city does not have a diamond district, your best bet would be to shop for the gems online. Buy from a vendor offering a favorable return policy, whether online or offline.